Better Economy, Worse Life? How GDP and Other Economic Metrics Fail Us.

Date Published:

Welcome to a new Eon, a channel on the tipping points and transitions driving unprecedented changes of the 21st century, today focusing on how economic metrics can support policies that exacerbate rather than address some of our biggest problems. So what’s an economy?

USA Illustrates the problem.

Economics vs Eggonomics: What’s an economy?

An economy for all, vs “economy for farm owners”

My definition, the goal of an economy is to facilitate the greatest enduring quality of life for its population. If you disagree, please let me know in the comments. But here’s how this fits with definitions given by others. All leave two challenging key questions, whose quality of life counts and how do we determine the greatest collective quality of life? First the who and

Economics vs Eggonomics:

Who is the economy for?

that’s on screen alternatives, the general population, a typical household, major shareholders and controlling investors, the wealthy, major asset owners, political leaders and governing parties, government institutions.

It’s very difficult for policies to focus equally on all groups. And if an economy could provide everyone with a better life while actually producing less, employing fewer working hours and generating less monetary expenditure, would we still recognize that as an economic success? It all comes down to that question of who? Is the economy about quality of life or farm production with us like chickens in an egg farm producing eggs for farm owners, as in my economics analogy.

Other analogies of how it can feel like we exist to serve the economy include Pink Floyd’s, “Another Brick in the Wall” and the film series The “The Matrix”. But I prefer the eggonomics analogy because rather than the economy being a machine that works for no one, it acknowledges the economy always works for some, even when it feels like it’s not working for most.

Governments play politics and focus on metrics that work for them, key donors and lobbyists.

Note these metrics were not designed just to work for one specific group. And any unbalanced outcomes weren’t intended by the original metrics.

Metrics

But that brings us to the metrics. How do we determine the greatest collective quality of life? GDP, employment, stock market indices should in theory be about the pursuit of these goals. But, that metrics can be problematic and fail to deliver? It’s well known, no secret and even studied. What’s most surprising is the lack of awareness that metrics are a problem.

Why? Possibly because many of those best placed to increase awareness don’t see them as real issues due to their own confirmation bias. Reality is greatest quality of life is like a vague concept.

You can only measure indicators, and Goodhart’s law highlights a specific problem with indicators. “When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure. Consider the example of fire stations. Cities with the least fires have the least fire stations. But if you made how many fire stations a city has as a metric, then people will just reduce the number of fire stations and that won’t reduce the fires. May sound simplistic, but it’s part of the same principle that can apply with GDP and the economy.

History of metrics and GDP.

Measuring GDP is hard, is clear from its history.

Back before 1930, it was considered a thing, but hard to measure. Really wasn’t widely adopted until World War Two. And in the aftermath, the United Nations published the first system of national accounts, creating an international framework for GDP. So it’s really only been used as a measure since the late 1940s. And as you can see, that started well.

Initially, there was a strong correlation between GDP and living standards. Now what we’re looking at here is history of productivity versus hourly compensation, where productivity is a key factor driving GDP. And while hourly compensation isn’t living standards, it’s a key factor driving living standards. And as you can see, the two track really well up until close to 1980. But then it breaks. Productivity keeps increasing and hourly compensation stays flat.

This is before even considering that with a growing population, the GDP is feeding not just the productivity per worker, but a big number of workers and growing even faster. And the more you research it, the more you find leading up to and certainly during the 21st century, increasing GDP has continually failed to deliver increasing living standards for the general population.

It’s a metric that worked well at first, but effectively has now become outdated. Going back to the who question, it still works for politicians, largest donors, and aligns with the goals of a high percentage of lobbyists. The OECD’s beyond GDP work specifically recognises that economic output distribution and wellbeing and sustainability, require different measurements, but they’re not adopted, because the pressure is not on, to change those metrics.

GDP in detail: The 5 key problems.

How GDP is Measured.

So, now to how you measure GDP and what are its key problems. Here’s the formula on screen.

It’s basically household consumption + business investment + government spending + the difference between exports and imports.

1. Measuring prodction through spending – feeds cost of living.

The first core problem of GDP is that measuring production by the amount spent encourages driving up the cost of living.

But everything’s measured by… by what people pay for it. How else do you measure the value of things produced than what people pay for? But there’s a key problem with this. Measuring production by how much is spent on it is the best method we’ve got, but it’s got a lot of problems. It effectively means counting the cost of something as an economic benefit. Damage, waste and inefficiency can generate additional economic activity. A more costly solution to a problem will contribute more to GDP than a cheaper, more effective solution. Now there is an argument that if the consumers are spending more, they must have more to spend. But to explain the problem with this, consider a person who can save for a house or pay down their loan on their house, or alternatively, not be able to save for a house because everything they earn is required to meet the cost of living. What this ignores is, household savings, paying down mortgages, or even borrowings. If wages were the entire source of spending, and all wages were always spent on the economy, then you’d be tracking a true increase in wages.

Now the problem isn’t that inflation is ignored. GDP does try to count for inflation. It’s just that it’s not perfect and doesn’t count things that require you to spend more. A simple example being that if cars become less economical, it requires you to purchase more fuel. That wouldn’t be addressed by inflation. And there are things in the economy that like needing to travel further to find work that drive up costs without being captured. And these factors drive up GDP, just as working from home and not needing to spend on fuel and not needing to buy meals out while you’re working reduces GDP and can be seen by governments as a problem.

Even though time on public transport is not necessarily very valuable to consumers, it’s valuable to GDP!

2. Measuring activity rather than outcomes erodes personal sovereignty & Independance.

And this leads into point 2: sovereignty.

Measuring activity rather than outcomes reduces personal sovereignty because it creates a pressure for everything to become a paid service provided by a provider and people less able to do things themselves.

Any product that requires follow-up services and continued expenditure drives up GDP.

GDP counts economic production, but not the benefits you get from it. For example, in a community with greater health problems, there’s more spending on healthcare.

But the actual outcome we want is better health, more spending on transport. What we prefer is people spend less time and money getting to work, more repairs and rebuilding. Well, that’s good if it results in better building, but not so good if it’s a result of frequent storms and weather damage or floods, all of which still produce GDP, more spending on security, be better if there was less crime, more firefighting activity, be better if there was less fires. It goes on and on. There’s a whole lot of spending that drives up GDP that we’d be a lot better off if we actually didn’t need. Then there’s measuring activity that really doesn’t need to be measured.

For example, doing your own gardening. Just imagine if there was a place that you couldn’t do your own gardening. You could offer services to your neighbour and do their gardening and they could do yours, but you have to pay each other. That would add a transaction in each case. It would increase GDP and it would increase tax revenue for the government potentially, but it wouldn’t get any more gardening done. There are other examples, like the economy suffers if grandparents offer childcare without a fee instead of childcare centres. Even people not owning their own homes actually lifts GDP. There’s a concept called imputed rent, which eliminates the rent itself trying to balance as if you’re paying your own rent. But there are a lot of other costs which aren’t captured and even imputed rent is typically an underestimate. Just property services and the way maintenance must be carried out on rental properties increases GDP. And this also feeds in to the coming AI and robots.

Consider all the things a robot could do. It could cook meals, clean your house, do plumbing, electrical. They could eventually do all sorts of tasks.

However, if you had your own robot, everything it did would reduce GDP.

It would be a disaster for the government’s metrics. They can’t really even let it happen unless they change the metrics.

Currently with our economy’s metrics, it makes it very difficult for individuals rather than corporations, to actually gain the benefits.

Problem 3: Ignoring what is sacrificed “for the economy”.

And now to our third point, ignoring what’s sacrificed to achieve an outcome, how quality of life is ignored. Everything is looked at from the perspective is that the goal is to grow output of the farm, which can be totally unaligned with quality of life. And it can also miss what are considered untaxed externals, costs that aren’t captured by current accounting. And this goes all the way through to including how renewables are adopted. It discourages energy sovereignty where consumers could use their own home solar. In fact, here in Australia, the whole country’s household domestic power supply could potentially be met by rooftop solar, but that’d be a disaster for the economy.

Underuse of rooftop solar to prioritise energy suppliers over consumers and nature. [https://youtu.be/L3-NOzgJLMM Underuse of rooftop solar to prioritise energy suppliers over consumers and nature]

Far better for GDP is remote solar farms that require the expense of build out of the power grid and push up power prices. And while lower power prices could be captured by inflation metrics, avoiding the need to buy power as opposed to forcing people to buy more power, that’s where GDP comes in.

everything, including personal time, where actual hours worked per person on average hasn’t declined since the 1950s.

Yes, we do have technically shorter working weeks, but this has been offset by professions that don’t capture the hours worked combined with the huge extra contribution to the labour force in terms of women going into paid employment. There is no focus on quality of life, and it also has other consequences.

4. GDP vs GDP per capita: Immigration crisis.

And while that point is mostly about what GDP fails to capture, the 4th point: GDP vs GDP per capita is an inherent design problem.

GDP is the perfect metric for governments and nationwide corporations and GDP per capita is the better measure for individuals. Which do we follow? Total GDP. And the first consequence is that all you need to do to grow GDP is grow the population. Even if people have less per person, you can offset that by just having more people. You end up with a refrain without immigration, the economy wouldn’t grow. Well,if the economy wouldn’t grow unless you grow the number of people, then the economy has a problem for individuals.

And there are further consequences. It results in planning around infinite population growth that just isn’t happening. If you ask AI to project an image of the future, it draws a city with huge towers, catering for three, four, and five times current populations.

Where would these people come from?

If you look at 1970s 20th century population trends, and they were to continue, then yes, you’d expect this to happen. But once you look at the bigger the 20th century was an exception. That’s actually impossible to maintain with a large part of the population growth driven not by birth rates, but by declining infant death rates, which basically is now a solved problem. It’s not going to keep feeding population growth.

But what we have, is countries with a population where birth rates are below replacement level.

But governments insisting they’re effectively going to replace the total population with immigration to enforce growth on a population that would otherwise be reducing and meaning the current population is a smaller and smaller percentage of the future until it eventually disappeared. Now that won’t happen because once you look at global population, the numbers of people required just aren’t going to exist. But this means governments in order to support GDP are promoting a dystopian future, that creates a revolt, and a huge immigration backlash, feeding some extreme right-wing suggestions.

5: No limits and housing crisis.

And this feeds into the next inherent problem in the whole concept behind GDP. It has a failure to respect any concept of a limit.

There’s a famous quote attributed to Kenneth Boulding, anyone who believes exponential growth can go on forever in a finite world is either a madman or an economist. The reality is everything has an optimum. Consider how few of us drink enough water, but it’s possible to die from drinking too much water. Effectively, GDP assumes you can never have enough widgets. And the more widgets you have, the better life will get. And that relationship began breaking down in the 1980s. Growth beyond those finite constraints increases the wealth of ever smaller percentage who own sufficiently beyond the average level of assets, creating an asset affordability crisis that includes housing.

Other Indicators.

GDP is not the only metric.

What’s next is to consider how other metrics exacerbate the problems that arise from GDP,

1. Stock Market Indices.

with the next metric being stock market values. And shares go up if companies can make the greatest profit. And the greatest profit means the biggest difference between the price they sell something for and the cost of making it. If you can convince people to buy things that are very cheap for a very high price, it’s not really great for consumers, but it’s great for stock market values. And most indices only measure the biggest companies. Effectively, all you need to grow the stock market is to concentrate the economy into fewer and fewer bigger companies. There’s an example to follow on supermarkets and how it all fits together. And not to forget some of the biggest companies historically that have grown the stock market over the time have included tobacco, gambling and other products that are really questionable about how much they actually despite the fact that they generate huge windfalls on the stock market.

It also encourages privatising every government service in order to grow the stock market. And the reality is some government services are inherently a monopoly, which creates a problem when privatized and don’t work well with the profit motive. But that’s for a whole other video.

Growing the stock market can also feed into cost of living. It’s that difference between people who gain most income from assets they already own growing in value versus those who sell their labor

2. Inflation. Why isn’t the target zero?

And next inflation.

And just in case you’re not aware, most governments deliberately target to have around at least 2% per annum inflation. Why deliberately targeting rising prices? Well, there’s a whole list of theoretical reasons. In theory, it makes debt shrink, but then interest on debt tends to offset that to take that into account. It makes reducing wages easier without actually making wage cuts. And it allows monetary flexibility. But the reason has become the most heavily debated. The theory is that if prices weren’t rising, everyone would delay their purchases, there’d be less transactions and GDP would shrink.

But there’s a big problem with this.

Have you ever bought a flat screen TV or a computer? Technology continually decreases in price?

Yet, we still buy it. And there’s a principle called Wright’s law, which is that every manufactured item effectively becomes cheaper the more that are made. All the money spent on manufactured goods actually has like reverse inflation built in, as illustrated by this, the refrigerator problem.

Over time, for the same level of refrigerator, it’s going to get cheaper. But in order for that producer drag on inflation, the things you put in the refrigerator are going to keep going up in price. And despite the argument that inflation prevents people stalling their expenses, the things that inflation drives up in price are things like food. And it’s really hard to put off that expenditure compared to an upgraded refrigerator or television set, the things that go down in price that we could put off spending on. But the fact that the pricing becomes more actually keeps us buying. The whole logic is now being questioned by very significant economists with the strategic question, if technology can make life more affordable, why is rising consumer prices our definition of stability?

And the end result is it’s good for the economy, but it’s not necessarily good for people.

3. More Jobs? Always?

And last jobs, you’ll often hear politicians promoting how their policies create more jobs, not better jobs, not more rewarding jobs, not not necessarily higher paid jobs, just more total jobs. And you can have this announcement about more jobs. On the same day, the central bank announces, oh, unemployment is below the target band. And we need to take steps to reduce the demand for employment.

So why are governments so fixated with jobs, even when unemployment is below the target band? Basically, because it creates this labor shortage growth loop, where there’s a demand to bring more people into the economy, who will pay more taxes and result in more expenditure. Even if it’s less tax and less expenditure per person, it doesn’t matter if you can grow the number of people enough.

It comes back to GDP vs GDP per capita bringing immigration back into focus and being the most significant clash between altruistic humanitarian migration and the problematic reality driving immigration backlash. Now, whether immigration needs higher or lower is a separate question. But you have to look at the motivation. In Australia, one party saying they reduce the numbers was met by suggestions of look at the tax revenue you’ll lose! This will reduce size of the economy! And create a shortfall of tax revenue!

But, without considering the taxes are to provide services for people, and if you bring in more people, you inherently need more tax.

It was all on one side of the argument, without looking at the balance. With the actual biggest flaw being that immigration can forever push up population growth. At some point, there is a limit. It’s one of the inherent problems in economic modeling.

Combined Impact of GPD and other indicators.

Examinging combined impact of GPD, Stock Market Indices, Inflation and “Jobs”.

So how does this all combine?

Consider a supermarket chain replacing independent grocers. Before you have more competition, more consumer choice, and wealth spread across many owners. In theory, the big supermarket chain could lower prices. But if it did that, it’d be bad for GDP. And the end result tends to be the same groceries sold by a bigger corporate chain. And yes, the costs are lower, but they’re not passed on to consumers which would hurt GDP, so as to maximize growth in the stock market.

And the fewer competitors there are, the more ways they find to effectively hide inflation by substituting goods and other measures available to big corporations. The end result is a greater concentration of corporate wealth, reduced competition, less consumer choice, and a bigger role for listed companies. The benefits to the economy? Significant.

But the benefits to the consumers? Far more questionable.

Conclusion: Without a change of metrics, expect it to get worse.

It becomes a game of monopoly, in need of a reset.

In the end, what we’ve found is the five loopholes in GDP highlight how the economy can actually conflict with different dimensions of human flourishing.

Measuring GDP by measuring expenditure goes straight against affordability. Measuring the economy by transactions instead of outcomes goes against personal independence and sovereignty, and against the adoption of autonomy and any benefits from AI.

The failure to consider the negative consequences of GDP growth and the failure to actually even try and measure quality of life, has impacts beyond what is measured economically, reducing Considering what was discussed in sovereignty and the environment, where proposed solutions to climate tend to favour those that drive up prices, even when there are ways to reduce prices.

And while the cost of living crisis is fed by that measuring production through spending, GDP versus GDP per capita creates a false narrative on immigration that results in an immigration crisis, and the failure to recognise limits drives a housing crisis. All of these to be addressed in separate videos.

Overall, we come back to that modified definition of insanity.

Continuing to pay others to pursue the same economic metrics but have been proven to increasingly fail isn’t going to deliver the steps forward in quality of life that we should have. Yes, they work for a select few, and those select few have power and they’re going to push for keeping the standards. If we want to move back to living standards improve generation after generation, we need new metrics. For more on the tipping points driving the need for change, please like, subscribe and add your comments below.

[TheChamp-Sharing]
[TheChamp-FB-Comments]

Table of Contents

Categories

The Irony of The Bloomberg 2020 Campaign

From a variety of media reports, I had the impression that Bloomberg first held off entering the nomination race because as long as Joe Biden had it covered. But now, Bloomberg could emerge as assisting Bernie Sanders to defeat Job Biden.

Read More »